Reserving Space for Bungaku Shoujo Ghost’s Scanlation Releases’ issues

Personally, I don’t want my first post after about a year of disappearance to simply just criticizing stuff, but the fact is that they’ve ignored my 1st email notified them about the issues in their release back in November 2012. And in the 2nd email, sent on the 7th of March, I’ve told them about the simplest error to find in 2 of the currently released chapter of Bungaku Shoujo Ghost, missing pages, and explicitly asked them to reply to that email for further conversation on other issues; but so far they’ve stayed silent.

The missing pages are on chapter 02 & 05.

I’ll be away from the internet for about 1 week, and if they still refuse to reply by then, the list of errors shall be disclosed.

Late edit 14-Nov; so basically this is what happened:

Below is the rest of the email with the errors listed:


Here is the missing pages on your 02 & 05: http://sdrv.ms/11ogqW7
I have one more extra page from the mag scan of ch02 regarding the Memoirs OVA-3 but since it seems like you skip over all extra pages so I didn’t include it in the above zip.

Regarding TL/edit of:
The single error in 02:
pg02:
>What he learned returning home shocked him. / He dragged the girl who betrayed him down to hell, and returned to the earth to wander it, seeking atonement / but she was still dead. She who was half his soul was dead.
*What he learned upon coming back to Japan shocked him. / The other half of his soul; the one who betrayed him; the one who dragged him to hell; / the sole reason, he came back to Japan with vengeance on his mind is already dead?
+2 options for the last words, “already dead” or “no more”.

ch03: http://www.evernote.com/shard/s256/sh/d2fc896c-0d7e-49da-ba3c-d9955d90147f/bc614a5f7c0944bf48e5ecaa402dfd33
ch04: http://www.evernote.com/shard/s256/sh/204e0d88-def3-457a-a35f-416c04ec3c24/d4a1d292b1be932526b0386502d6f9a8
ch05: http://www.evernote.com/shard/s256/sh/4e19903e-f22c-4f3f-a753-8f3e79eb7156/2e2c3f60a680b7fd38322e8c15f963ba
ch06: http://www.evernote.com/shard/s256/sh/058ece89-280d-4e48-aba6-a3502b97530a/e42239414144a17dc0af5d0529ce1b56
ch07: http://www.evernote.com/shard/s256/sh/1d7e3134-08f1-4072-97d7-962c294f2496/f972cffb66b1e8c6b812d428f1e6526f
For 06&07 I only did a quick check and I can still overlook stuff.

As you may know, Bungaku Shoujo Ghost is inspired by Wuthering Height so here’s what I remembered to copied the part that Ghost have/will quote:
http://www.evernote.com/shard/s256/sh/a86411e2-571c-4bbf-bdfb-a7e2ec6c863a/a651120684c566eafe5acbdbf5d50d77

About FD2Raptor

Basically an INTJ with interest in language. Insanely easy to get bored and have indifferent attitude to many things.
This entry was posted in Bungaku Shoujo and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.